MEDORA, N.D. — When Meridian Energy Group set out to develop “the cleanest refinery on the planet,” it chose a spot in western North Dakota’s oil patch near highways, railroads and a picturesque national park named for a former president revered for his conservation advocacy.
Now the longtime former leader of Theodore Roosevelt National Park, the state's top tourist attraction drawing a record 760,000 visitors last year, is among those urging officials to deny a permit for the 700-acre refinery due to pollution concerns.
"To put an oil refinery within view of the park would be a betrayal of the conservation values of the park's namesake," said retired longtime Park Superintendent Valerie Naylor, an outspoken opponent of the project.
"An oil refinery has no business at the doorstep of a national park. We wouldn't allow an oil refinery to be built within view of Yellowstone or Yosemite, and it should be no different for Theodore Roosevelt."
Meridian, formed by a partnership with agricultural interests in North Dakota to develop the refinery, plans to push forward on the $900 million project, which it says will be a model for environmentally friendly technology.
The proposed Davis Refinery would process up to 55,000 barrels of Bakken crude per day into a variety of fuels while creating 500 construction jobs and permanent jobs for 200 people in the area, and generating millions of dollars in property taxes for the county each year.
"We're trying to do everything so that from the park perspective, you can't hear it, see it, smell it or anything else,"
Meridian Energy Group
Because of its proximity to the national park, it must meet more stringent air quality standards, which the company says it will achieve through the most modern emissions control technology.
"Refineries are not pleasant things. Most in this country are 40, 50 years or older. They're not the kind of thing you'd want to see in your neighbourhood, if there was a park there or not," Meridian CEO William Prentice said.
"We've taken all these concerns into consideration. This will be the cleanest refinery on the planet when it's done."
Many people, including National Park Service officials, aren't so sure, and worry the refinery will add to haze from coal-fired power plants in the region and other sources such as vehicles on nearby Interstate 94.
"Our concern is when you go to viewpoints in the park, you'd get a view that's clear and would capture the colours and features, things it's famous for," said Park Service environmental engineer Don Shepherd.
"One of the neat things about Theodore Roosevelt is all the colours you see in the rock strata. On a bad (haze) day you might notice the colour not as vivid or clear to the eye."
Roosevelt ranched in the region in the 1880s and is known for his advocacy of land and wildlife conservation.
His namesake park is in the heart of the North Dakota Badlands, a rugged and breathtaking area of hills, ridges, buttes and bluffs where millions of years of erosion have exposed colorful sedimentary rock layers.
"An oil refinery and associated industrial development would fundamentally threaten the pristine air and other conservation values that our nation committed to protect when we created Theodore Roosevelt National Park,"
National Parks Conservation Association
The park is home to spectacular scenery and a wide variety of wildlife, from prairie dog towns to wild horses and bison.
Besides taking in the scenery, visitors can hike, bike, camp and fish.
Park Superintendent Wendy Ross said a study of the refinery's initial design concluded that parts of the plant would be visible from about two per cent of the 30,000-acre park.
Prentice said lighting will be subdued, the refinery will have colour schemes designed to blend into the terrain and there will be limited flaring of excess natural gas.
The company also is working with North Dakota State University on natural buffers such as native trees to help hide the refinery from tourists coming to the park on the interstate.
"We're trying to do everything so that from the park perspective, you can't hear it, see it, smell it or anything else," Prentice said.
The project has still drawn opposition from national groups such as the National Parks Conservation Association and The Coalition to Protect America's National Parks, and questions from local residents.
Linda Weiss, a longtime resident of the nearby small town of Belfield, said there are "a lot of unknowns" in the community about the refinery.
"It's going to be visible," she said.
"They may put up tree barriers, but it takes a while for those to grow."
Zachary Kreps, a Moorhead, Minnesota, resident and park enthusiast, started a refinery opposition petition online.
"During my childhood, we used to go out for summer vacations practically every summer out to (the park). To hear they're going to be putting a refinery three miles away from it just kind of struck a chord," he said.
The Health Department's decision on an air quality permit for the refinery could take up to a year.
The analysis could delay the planned summer groundbreaking, but that isn't deterring Meridian.
"We're going to essentially be raising the bar for every other refinery in the country," Prentice said.
Opponents hope that doesn't come at the expense of the park.
"An oil refinery and associated industrial development would fundamentally threaten the pristine air and other conservation values that our nation committed to protect when we created Theodore Roosevelt National Park," said Bart Melton, regional director for the National Parks Conservation Association.